Showing posts with label fan service. Show all posts
Showing posts with label fan service. Show all posts

Monday, November 11, 2013

Free! controversy



In my previous blog post I talked about an anime that has amazed me this summer. However, some might not realize how incredibly close it was to not existing all together. 

Fan service as you know it

The initiated anime watcher is probably already quite familiar with the term ‘fan service’. Not that it is a phenomenon only restricted to animes, as it is present in films, comics and other media as well, but it is a bit more noticeable in Japanese animation, as it can be extremely over-the-top. A prime example of just how silly it can get would probably be the “matrix breasts scene” from High school of the dead (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CKBKLvI8F8A).
The second thing that is very influential in anime fan service is the demographic. While the exact gender divide of the demographic can vary from one poll to another, the majority believes that most of the demographic are males and thus get the most attention when marketing anime. In practical terms, this means that ‘fan service’ are mostly selective camera angles, mostly highlighting pride female assets, or female character with cute or/and attractive traits such as the ‘moe’ archetype.
Fan service aimed at girls is mostly found in the ‘shojo’ genre of anime, where the story mostly revolves round a couple’s journey of getting together, or in the ‘yaoi’ genre involving relationships between two males.

Free phenomenon

As stated in the pas section, to create an anime with fan service aimed at girls outside of those two genres was virtually unheard of, at least not in such an obvious way. Free! was the first one to step out of the line, but it started primarily due to fan initiative.
Originally, Free! was released as a small animated short from Kyoto Animations, just about one half of a minute long. The intent was not to announce a new swimming anime, but to show off their water animation. However, the short quickly spread around the female community, particularly the site Tumblr. The pressure on the animation studio was so high they eventually announced a full length anime due for the summer season.

Backlash

Just the proposal was heavily criticized by the male anime community. The main problem was not just the anime concept itself, which was said to be an anime with fan service for girls, but also the production studio. Kyoto Animation was, as mentioned in my former post, formally famous for producing a lot of anime titles that pandered to the male anime watchers by showing cute little girls going about their daily lives doing cute things, such as K-on for example. To think that the studio would do a 180 with a show that featured guys undressing at regular intervals was incomprehensible to some. Certain people even went as far as believing it’s just a high-budget addition to the yaoi genre, other argue that it is presenting unrealistic expectations of the male body.

The truth?

It is hard to be completely objective about these things, so you’ll have to take my opinion for it.
There is fan service in the show and it is relatively easy to pin down where. Firstly it is in the camera angles that are, as with most fan service, conveniently placed for you to get a good look at the well-drawn stomachs and, in some cases, even the rears. The other use of fan service is a bit more subtle, but still fairly noticeable. While none of the characters in the anime are clearly homosexual, there are some suggestive moments between the cast that were obviously there to make the fujioshis* have a collective ‘fangasm’.
However, the fan service is more of a flavor on the side, a choice in detailing rather than the driving force of the plot. After all, the contraction of clothes is usually required before going into the water. The story doesn’t make jarring turns or completely unreasonable decisions to get the characters to behave a certain way, but it seems to be their inward motivation.
That is why I advise you not to get discouraged from seeing this anime, particulary if you enjoy slife-of-life comedy and judge it yourself.